Litigation support investigations are the fact-finding work a private investigator does for an attorney or a party to a dispute: locating and interviewing witnesses, verifying claims, documenting scenes, tracing assets and running background checks. The American Bar Association describes this work as collecting information and evidence about parties, potential witnesses and jurors in litigation matters. Done well, it gives counsel verified facts before a complaint is filed, before depositions are scheduled and before a settlement number is set. Done badly, it can expose privileged material or taint the evidence. This guide covers what the work includes, how it is structured so it holds up, and what to settle before you hire anyone.

Hub Security and Investigative Group
hubsecurityandinvestigativegroup.com
Investigative Support for Legal Matters
Hub’s Massachusetts private investigators handle investigations, background checks and process serving for attorneys and law firms.

Explore investigative services

TL;DR

Table of Contents

What litigation support investigations include

Attorneys are trained to argue facts, not to go out and find them. An investigator fills that gap, using lawful methods to obtain information that a case depends on. In practice the work falls into a handful of categories.

Witness location and interviews

Witnesses move, change phone numbers and forget details. An investigator locates them early, while memories are fresh, and can take recorded statements from people who are not represented by counsel. Interviews of represented parties are a different matter, because lawyers are bound by professional conduct rules about contacting them. That is one reason the investigator’s instructions should come from the attorney.

Scene documentation and public records

In a personal injury, premises liability or property dispute, the physical scene changes quickly. Investigators photograph and video the location, measure it and note conditions such as lighting, signage and obstructions. They also pull public records: court filings, property records, corporate registrations and similar documents. The ABA’s pre-suit case plan guidance lists these tasks, along with obtaining relevant insurance policies and checking the backgrounds of the client and key witnesses, and it warns against trespass and improper invasions of privacy.

Surveillance

Surveillance tests claims about physical ability, activity and whereabouts. It is common in workers’ compensation, disability, insurance fraud and family matters. The value of surveillance depends entirely on documentation: a timed, minute-by-minute log and the original, unedited media. We explain what a client should receive in our page on what to expect from a surveillance investigation, and you can see how we run these assignments on our surveillance investigation page.

Background checks on parties and witnesses

A witness with a prior judgment, an undisclosed relationship to a party or a history of inconsistent statements changes how counsel prepares. Background checks on potential witnesses surface these issues before the other side does. For financial questions, courthouse records are usually more reliable than aggregated database results, a point we make in our piece on financial background checks.

Asset searches

A judgment is worth only what can be collected. Asset search investigations identify real estate, business interests, accounts and transfers that may matter for settlement or enforcement. They are also useful earlier, when a plaintiff wants to know whether a defendant can pay at all. Tracing and reconstructing financial activity often pairs an investigator with a forensic accountant, and counsel who need expert witness and litigation support accounting can bring one in once the investigator has located and organized the underlying records.

Open-source research

Public social media posts, corporate filings, news archives and other open sources can corroborate or contradict testimony. The ABA notes that open-source intelligence is used in civil and criminal cases and in due diligence, provided it complies with federal law such as the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and with ethical rules. Practically, that means no logging into accounts you are not authorized to use and no breaking a platform’s terms to get at content. Our overview of OSINT in modern investigation explains the method, and our guide to vetting social media probes covers the questions Massachusetts employers should ask first.

Process serving

A case cannot move until the other side is properly served. Locating an evasive defendant and serving papers correctly is investigative work in its own right, and it is part of what we handle for law firms.

Process server handing papers to recipient

Pre-litigation investigation: what to gather before filing

The cheapest time to investigate is before you file. A pre-suit investigation tells you whether a claim is worth bringing, whom to name and what the other side is likely to say.

The ABA’s pre-suit case plan outlines a sensible sequence for counsel:

  1. Preserve evidence. Send preservation notices and secure documents and tangible items before they are lost or altered.
  2. Check backgrounds. Review your own client and the key witnesses, so nothing surprises you in discovery.
  3. Take statements. Record statements from unrepresented witnesses while their recollection is clear.
  4. Document the scene. Inspect it, photograph it and shoot video.
  5. Collect records. Obtain public records and the relevant insurance policies.

Notice what this list does not include: anything that depends on deception about identity to get protected information, trespass, or surveillance that intrudes on private spaces. A good investigator says no to those requests, and a good attorney does not make them. Our page on private investigator ethics covers where we draw those lines.

A pre-litigation investigation also helps with expectations. If the facts are weaker than the client believed, you learn that before paying filing fees and discovery costs. If they are stronger, you can write a demand letter that reflects what you can prove.

Corporate due diligence investigations

Due diligence is a close cousin of litigation support. Instead of preparing for a dispute, you are trying to avoid one, or to price the risk of one before you commit money.

In a private merger or acquisition, a buyer’s inquiry looks at the parties and at the business or assets for sale. According to a due diligence guide for private M&A, the review may cover title, liabilities and risks, value, operations, integration steps and impediments to the deal. The result can support contractual protections, a purchase-price adjustment or a decision to walk away. Bloomberg Law’s due diligence overview adds ownership, financial information, litigation and regulatory matters, and required consents to that list.

The investigative layer sits on top of the paperwork a seller provides. It asks whether the information is true and complete:

This is not only a domestic concern. The U.S. Department of Commerce advises exporters to perform due diligence on a market’s political, economic and financial conditions, to select foreign partners and buyers carefully, and to keep doing so as they expand. For Massachusetts companies with overseas distributors or suppliers, that includes verifying who they are dealing with. Our due diligence investigation service in Massachusetts covers this kind of review, and our note on verifying identity in international background checks explains why identity comes first.

Privilege and work product: the part that decides whether the work is protected

This is where litigation support investigations most often go wrong, and it is worth slowing down.

No investigator privilege

Under U.S. law, there is no common law private investigator-client privilege and no private investigator work product doctrine of its own. If a business owner hires an investigator directly to look into a dispute, the investigator’s notes and report may be reachable by the other side. Protection comes through the attorney.

How counsel creates protection

Two doctrines matter. The work-product doctrine protects the mental processes, thoughts and opinions of counsel developed in anticipation of litigation. Attorney-client privilege requires, according to Baker Botts’ investigations toolkit, that the investigation be directed and supervised by counsel for the purpose of giving legal advice to the client.

The ABA guidance on hiring an investigator makes the practical point: outside counsel should document that the investigation relates to contemplated litigation and should give the investigator instructions. A short engagement letter from the attorney to the investigator, stating the purpose, the scope and the reporting line, does a lot of work here.

Waiver

Privilege can be lost by sharing. Counsel and investigators should limit who sees privileged material, because passing reports around creates waiver risk. In federal proceedings, Federal Rule of Evidence 502 governs the waiver of attorney-client privilege and work-product protection. Which rules apply in your matter depends on the court, so ask your attorney, not your investigator.

Who should run an internal investigation

For allegations of high-level misconduct, the American College of Trial Lawyers has noted that investigations tend to carry more credibility with regulators when independent outside counsel conducts them rather than the company’s regular general counsel. If that describes your situation, bring in outside counsel first and let them retain the investigator.

Our perspective on litigation support work

We have been in business since 2004, and the pattern we see most often is this: the investigation was fine, but the instructions around it were not. A client calls an investigator on day one, before talking to a lawyer, and then discovers that nothing about the engagement was structured to be protected.

Our advice is practical. Call your attorney first, and let the attorney define the question. The most useful assignments we receive are narrow and specific: locate this witness, document this location, verify these assets, establish this person’s daily pattern. Vague requests produce expensive, unfocused reports.

We also encourage attorneys to ask us for the evidence standard they want before we start. Timed logs, original media files, chain of custody for anything collected and a clear separation between what we observed and what we infer are what make an investigator’s work usable. A report that reads like advocacy is easy to attack.

Finally, we keep our work in-house. We never use subcontractors, so the person your attorney speaks with at the outset is a Hub professional, and the people who do the field work are our own. When an investigator may one day testify about how evidence was obtained, knowing exactly who did what matters.

— Derek

The ABA’s guidance says counsel should review an investigator’s qualifications, license status, insurance, investigative practices and proposed work-product delivery before hiring. It also lists the risks of getting this wrong: vicarious liability for torts, direct liability for negligent hiring or supervision, and the possibility that investigation results are exposed in litigation. Use that as a checklist.

What to checkWhat a good answer looks like
LicenseCurrent license that you can verify with the state. See our guide to verifying a Massachusetts private investigator license.
InsuranceProof of general liability coverage, provided on request.
MethodsA plain description of how information will be obtained, with refusal of anything unlawful.
ReportingWritten reports directed to counsel, with logs, media and sources identified.
StaffingWho actually does the work, and whether any of it is subcontracted.
TestimonyWillingness and ability to be a fact witness if needed.

A few questions are worth asking out loud. Has the investigator worked with attorneys before, and do they understand why reports go to counsel? What will they refuse to do? How quickly can they start, and how will they communicate while the work is underway?

On our side, Hub is licensed in Massachusetts as a private detective firm (License #LP0203L) and carries $3 million in general liability insurance. If you want to see how we work with counsel, our page for law firms in Boston is a good place to start.

Our investigators handle surveillance, background checks, asset searches, corporate investigations, due diligence, insurance fraud investigations, missing persons work and process serving. Attorneys and in-house teams in Massachusetts can reach us through our private investigator services page or see the full list on our services page. Tell us the question you need answered and the timeline, and we will scope the assignment around it, with reports directed the way your counsel instructs.

If a case also involves physical safety, such as a hostile termination or a contentious deposition, we can pair investigative work with uniformed or executive protection from our own staff.

Limits worth knowing

Investigation does not create facts that are not there. A good investigator will tell you when a lead is a dead end, and that is useful information for a litigant deciding whether to proceed.

A few other limits apply in every matter:

If you want to understand where private investigators differ from law enforcement in access and authority, see our comparison of police and private investigators.

FAQ

What is a litigation support specialist?

In the investigative context, it is a professional who supports the legal team with fact-finding: locating witnesses, gathering records, documenting evidence and verifying claims. The term is also used for people who manage document review and e-discovery technology. Check which meaning a provider intends before you hire.

Why would a lawyer hire a private investigator?

To collect information and evidence that the lawyer cannot gather personally and should not gather personally, particularly when the lawyer might otherwise become a witness. Investigators locate and interview witnesses, document scenes, check backgrounds, trace assets and conduct surveillance. Structured correctly through counsel, that work also supports work-product protection.

What does it mean when a case is going to litigation?

It means the dispute has moved from negotiation to a formal lawsuit in court, with pleadings, discovery, motions and possibly trial. Investigation is most valuable before this stage, because it shapes the claim, and during discovery, when facts must be verified.

Is an investigator’s report confidential?

Not automatically. U.S. law has no private investigator privilege, so protection generally depends on the investigation being directed by an attorney in anticipation of litigation. Ask your attorney how to structure the engagement before work begins.

Sources